| Pastors | |
|---|---|
| Dr. Rev. Parrish L. Bridges | 2020 – 2023 |
| Skip Seibel | 2016 – 2020 |
| John Minihan | 2011 – 2016 |
| Roger Rabey | 1999 – 2009 |
| Ernest Trice Thompson, Jr. | 1987 – 1998 |
| Lynn Temple Jones | 1964 -1985 |
| Andrew Reid Bird, Jr. | 1943 -1963 |
| Armand London Currie | 1933 -1942 |
| John Blanton Belk | 1929 -1933 |
| Joseph Layton Mauze | 1917 -1928 |
| Newton Donaldson | 1893-1916 |
| Joseph Milton Sloan | 1885 -1893 |
| Colin Alexander Munroe | 1884 -1885 |
| John Calvin Brown | 1882 -1883 |
| Goodridge Alexander Wilson | 1877 -1879 |
| James N. Brown | 1876 -1877 |
| John David McClintock | 1863 -1876 |
| John Clark Bayless | 1861 -1863 |
| A.J. McMillen | 1858 -1861 |
| John Clark Bayless | 1854 -1858 |
| Josiah B. Poage | 1843-1850 |
| Alfred E. Thom | 1838 -1842 |
| Associate Pastors* | |
|---|---|
| Joshua Sutherlun | 2009 -2013 |
| Amy Sutherlun | 2005 -2013 |
| Skip Seibel | 2002 -2016 |
| William dePrater | 1992 -1999 |
| Karl Douglas Gustafson | 1987 -1991 |
| Edward Wammack Donnell | 1979 -1988 |
| Donald Richard Weiglein | 1978 -1995 |
| Richard Obee Comfort | 1972 -1983 |
| Jerry David Harrah | 1969-1970 |
| Gray Watson Hampton, Jr. | 1968 -1978 |
| Harry Frederick Petersen | 1965 -1967 |
| Charles Richard Frissell | 1963 -1965 |
| Henry Seymour Robinson, Jr | 1962 – 1963 |
| Hubert Jess Kaylor | 1960 -1965 |
| Dunbar Hunt Ogden, Jr. | 1959 – 1961 |
| Lawrence Aaron Davis | 1953-1957 |
| Gallie Franklin King | 1943 -1960 |
| E. Harrison Hamilton | 1950-1951 |
| John James Hayes, Jr. | 1949 -1963 |
| James Gordon Riggan | 1949-1950 |
| Joseph McMurray Owen | 1946 -1948 |
| Charles Alexander Logan | 1944-1947 |
| Carl Lloyd Arehart | 1937 -1938 |
| Joseph Layton Mauze, Jr. | 1935 -1937 |
| F.W. Archibald Boach | 1927 -1928 |
| Lewis Bevens Schenck | 1924-1926 |
*Including Mission Pastors and Ministers of Christian Education